Jason Merritt/Getty; John Shearer/AP; Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic
02/25/2013 AT 05:50 PM EST
In order to earn a spot in the PEOPLE.com Oscars Best Dressed gallery, a gown must do one of two things: get the unanimous approval of the entire PEOPLE.com style staff…or wow one editor so much that she's prompted to start a campaign to get that star's look on the list (cough, Kerry Washington, cough).
Most of the names you see below fall under the former category, but there might be one or two fashion-forward looks that landed on the list because an editor was able to convince the team. Take a look and see if you can guess which those are. 1. JENNIFER LAWRENCE
We don't want to brag … okay, yes we do. We totally called this Dior Haute Couture number
for the Best Actress nominee
. She outdoes our expectations, though, pairing it with a Roger Vivier clutch and zillions of carats of Chopard jewels, including a dazzling necklace worn down her back.
See the photo here.2. JESSICA CHASTAIN
"It was a very tough decision," the Oscar nominee
says of her copper embellished custom Giorgio Armani gown, accessorized with Harry Winston diamonds, soft waves and the perfect red lip. Maybe so, but it was certainly the right
See the photo here.
3. REESE WITHERSPOON
We might have selected Jennifer's dress, but it was Reese's
daughter who helped pick out this two-tone Louis Vuitton creation, worn with gorgeous cascading waves. "She's 13, she really
weighs in," the actress revealed of her young stylist.
See the photo here.4. AMY ADAMS
shows off her tiny waist (and penchant for dramatic dresses) in a silver-gray Oscar de la Renta gown with a beaded bodice and a massive, tulle-embellished skirt. She finishes the look with delicate jewelry and what just may be the night's prettiest undo.
See the photo here.5. CHARLIZE THERON
Who needs a statue when you look this statuesque? Charlize
makes the most dramatic entrance of the evening thanks to her edgy crop, Harry Winston jewels and this pristine white peplum Dior Haute Couture, which prompted her to say, "I sometimes just really feel like a princess."
See the photo here.6. NAOMI WATTS
It'll be tough to out-dazzle the Impossible actress,
whose fully sequined gunmetal Armani Privé gown features an asymmetric neckline and easily won over the PEOPLE.com editors. (Oh, and for those of you keeping count: She's also wearing $1.5 million of Neil Lane diamonds.)
See the photo here.7. KERRY WASHINGTON
"It's a coral-y, red, hot pink thing. I can't put a name on the color, which I love," the Django Unchained
star explains of the reason she picked her simple Miu Miu gown with its bejeweled bodice. She also knocks it out of the park with her accessories: a Prada clutch, Chopard earrings, a Fred Leighton ring and Christian Louboutin heels.
See the photo here.8. STACY KEIBLER
Also predicting Oscar gowns accurately? Designer Naeem Khan, who guessed
that we'd see this elegant beaded confection (paired with earrings and a bracelet by Lorraine Schwartz) on the red carpet tonight. Though we think he may have had a little insider info we didn't.
See the photo here.9. NICOLE KIDMAN
Major props to the Aussie actress
for taking this fashion risk – it definitely paid off! She stuns in a L'Wren Scott gown that looks practically liquid, hugging her curves and ending in golden swirls, then tops it all off with Fred Leighton jewelry.
See the photo here.10. SANDRA BULLOCK
Though she's there to present, the star
looks ready for center stage in her cap-sleeve Elie Saab gown with a sheer skirt, worn with Harry Winston jewels from her hair to her fingers, plus a vintage Daniel Swarovski clutch and Jimmy Choo heels.
See the photo here.11. JENNIFER GARNERAffleck's arm candy
fills the role beautifully yet again in a rich plum strapless Gucci gown with a dramatic back ruffle, plus $2.5 million worth of Neil Lane jewels including a 200 carat necklace, plus a Roger Vivier clutch.
See the photo here.12. KRISTEN STEWART
Despite having one of the night's most surprising accessories (a crutch), the actress
looks poised and pretty in what could be a wedding gown – check out that cream lace and the tulle skirt on her Reem Acra creation – plus vintage Fred Leighton diamonds and Jimmy Choo heels.
See the photo here.