Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart
01/15/2013 AT 02:35 PM EST
01/15/2013 AT 09:00 AM EST
Sean Lowe, you've got competition in the rose-giving department!
After Sunday's Golden Globes
, West Hollywood's Soho House hosted a private afterparty, where co-hosts Tina Fey
and Amy Poehler celebrated being the first female duo to ever host a major awards show.
Around midnight, the party began to move from the main bar to the outside bar. There, Robert Pattinson
"held court and joked around with Tina Fey," an onlooker tells PEOPLE. "He presented her with a red rose."
As Baileys cocktails flowed, Fey and Poehler traded their gowns for more casual wear and mingled with guests including Aziz Ansari
, Mad Men
's Jon Hamm
and girlfriend Jennifer Wesfeldt, Modern Family
's Ty Burrell
, Eric Stonestreet and Jesse Tyler Ferguson
's Damian Lewis
While at the bash, Pattinson also chatted with Les Misérables
star Eddie Redmayne
, Rashida Jones
and Ansari, who had something of his own to give to the Twilight
"Aziz tried to feed Rob some mac and cheese," the source says.
Later, Pattinson spent more time outside while waiting on Kristen Stewart
's arrival. Although Pattinson was dressed in a suit, Stewart sported a more casual look, wearing jeans, a sweatshirt and backwards trucker hat.
"They hung around each other, but [they weren't] on top of each other," the source says.
As the night progressed, Stewart chatted with Sienna Miller
, who was nominated for a Golden Globe for her role as Tippi Hedren in The Girl
– Melody Chiu