Last Night's Look: Love It or Leave It?Check out the head-turning outfits Rachel Bilson, Kim Kardashian and more stars were just spotted in! Then decide – fabulous or fashion fail?

BROOKE SHIELDS

Surprisingly, that medal isn't for Brooke's fashion sense. She stops by the 2012 Ellis Island Medals of Honor event in N.Y.C. in a mermaid-shaped black-and-white gown, a sparkly bangle and bright red lips.