15 Best Fashion Faceoffs of 2011

Pippa Middleton vs. Lindsay Lohan! Beyoncé vs. Julianne Hough! Have the final say on who wore her dress best this year

  • TAYLOR VS. KATIE photo | Katie Holmes, Taylor Swift

Credit: Christopher Polk/ACMA2010/Getty; Broadimage

Updated: Wednesday Dec 28, 2011 | 06:00 AM EST By: Alex Apatoff

More from PEOPLE

7 of 16

TAYLOR VS. KATIE

The singer sports a Contrarian New York dress in lavender with silver pumps last year, while the actress picks the black version and adds nude pumps in June.