Who Got It Right?

Hollywood's sexiest stars face-off in a hair and makeup showdown. You decide who rocked the trend – and who missed the beauty mark. Vote!

  • SMOKY EYES & RED LIPS photo | Mary-Kate Olsen, Scarlett Johansson

Credit: Richard Young/Startraks; Dennis Van Tine/LFI

Updated: Tuesday Oct 27, 2009 | 06:00 AM EDT By: Katherine Kluznik Rentmeester

SMOKY EYES & RED LIPS

There's no holding back Scarlett Johansson, who plays up her lips and her eyes with equally dark makeup, while Mary-Kate Olsen balances her look with a lighter bronze shadow.

Sorry! This poll has closed.