Fashion Faceoff

Sometimes, stylish star minds think alike. You decide: Who wears it better?

  • HILARY VS. ASHLEY  photo | Ashley Tisdale, Hilary Swank

Credit: Matthew Simmons/WireImage; Albert Michael/Startraks

Updated: Tuesday Aug 26, 2008 | 04:00 PM EDT

HILARY VS. ASHLEY

The Oscar winner was elegant in her Jill Stuart dress while being honored by Saks, while the High School Musical 3 star tried on the dress at the designer's N.Y.C. showroom.