Celeb Fashion Hit or Miss?

Vote on this week's styles including Eva Mendes, Nicole Richie and more stars! You decide – are they fashionistas or flops? By Andrea DeSimone and Melissa Liebling-Goldberg

MAGGIE GYLLENHAAL

Forget gowns – the actress turns up at the CFDA awards in a green and black plaid chiffon caftan and wrap pants by Proenza Schouler.