Stars' Day-to-Night Beauty

See Sandra Bullock, Dianna Agron and more stars go from fresh-faced in the afternoon to fully made up after dark, then tell us which makeup look you prefer

LILY COLLINS

As hard as it is, we're going to need you to pull your attention away from Lily's captivating bushy brows to vote on your favorite look. The actress pairs a soft pink lip with rosy cheeks and black liner while promoting her new film The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones during the day. But for the evening premiere, she amps up the drama selecting a deep berry pout, long spider lashes (we're guessing falsies) and shimmery metallic eyeshadows.