updated 06/07/2012 AT 12:00 AM ET
•originally published 06/06/2012 AT 9:15 PM ET
But the five-time nominee’s clearly not the only country crooner to whom Fisher was showing some support.
As Underwood, 29, accepted her first win of the night with Brad Paisley for their sultry single “Remind Me” (in the collaborative video of the year category), her duet partner seemed to have a new No. 1 fan.