Dated from 2011-2013 The former wrestler seemed to have what it takes to pin down the ultimate bachelor when their romance began heating up in the summer of 2011. "She's very tall. She can kick my ass," Clooney told E! News later that year, adding that Keibler's also a "nice girl." But after some cozy trips down the Oscars red carpet (and around the world!), news of their split broke on July 8. "She wants to have children and a family someday," a source tells PEOPLE. "She knows where George stands on that."