updated 03/21/2014 AT 9:50 AM ET
•originally published 03/19/2014 AT 4:00 PM ET
The Divergent star appeared on season 1 of the hit teen drama as Kaitlyn Cooper, the hairless-pony-loving little sister of Mischa Barton’s character, Marissa. Kaitlyn was shipped off to boarding school for season 2, and Woodley was subsequently replaced by actress Willa Holland. But she’s okay with that.
“I was 11 and I was on as a guest, recurring character, or whatever,” Woodley told Moviefone in 2011. “My character went to boarding school and when they decided to bring her back, they actually re-auditioned me to bring her back. But I didn’t go through puberty until late: I was the 15-year-old who had no boobs. So, at 11, I was like a little mouse-child. I looked like an 8-year-old.”
She added, “So, there was no weirdness when Willa Holland got it because she was so obviously right for the role … and I was so obviously not.”
Watch young Woodley in the above clip, from The O.C.’s 2003 pilot.
Related Video: Relive the Divergent Red Carpet in Under Two Minutes
Pick up the latest special issue from PEOPLE – on sale now!
Like us on Facebook for more stories like this!