updated 07/27/2012 AT 12:00 PM ET
•originally published 07/28/2012 AT 8:20 PM ET
Sorry, ladies: Mark-Paul Gosselaar is officially off the market.
One year after the Franklin & Bash star proposed to advertising executive Catriona McGinn, the couple said “I do” on Saturday at the Sunstone winery in Santa Ynez, Calif., a source confirms to PEOPLE exclusively.
“He was so excited to have found the woman of his dreams,” said Neil Lane, who designed the couple’s engagement rings and wedding bands. “He couldn’t wait to propose!”
“I’m too type-A to let it happen around me,” he said. “We’re trying to make it as traditional as possible. It’s going to be fun!”
Next, the former Saved by the Bell star and his new bride are heading to Italy for their honeymoon.
“Trust me, we are going to eat our a––es off!” he told PEOPLE. “We’re really excited about that element.”