updated 05/02/2012 AT 3:00 PM ET
•originally published 05/06/2012 AT 1:45 PM ET
If you’ve been to high school, chances are you’ve got a yearbook lying around that’s full of enough cringe-worthy quotes and photos to mortify you until your dying day.
Unless you’re Tina Fey, who’s pretty proud of hers.
Asked what quote she selected to be remembered by in the 1988 Upper Darby, Pa., high school yearbook, the 30 Rock star, 41, shared this clever gem with PEOPLE in its new issue.
“I had a good one,” she says. “We had to fill in the blank: ‘Five years from now I will be…’ and mine was ‘very, very fat.’ I figured if I’m not, then it’s like, ‘You’re not!’ And if I am, I’m like, ‘I know – I called it!’”
Reporting by CHARLOTTE TRIGGS
For more hilarious high school yearbook quotes from stars like Julianne Moore and Johnny Weir, pick up the latest issue of PEOPLE, on newsstands now