updated 06/06/2011 AT 8:00 AM ET
•originally published 06/06/2011 AT 10:00 AM ET
Are Cameron Diaz and Alex Rodriguez going to extra innings?
The pair, who reportedly broke up a few days ago, still seem to be gravitating toward each other when it comes to their nights out.
The actress, 38, and the New York Yankees slugger, 35, seemed quite the couple at the MTV Movie Awards afterparty, sponsored by Yoostar, at Soho House in West Hollywood Sunday night. “They left early holding hands. She was all smiles with him,” a source tells PEOPLE.