updated 12/03/2007 AT 2:00 PM ET
•originally published 12/03/2007 AT 5:00 PM ET
New York’s Beatrice Inn was doubly hot on Sunday night as Topher Grace and Atonement star James McAvoy stopped through separately, and then ended up at adjacent tables. There with a group, McAvoy and his pals took a table for two – then pulled up two extra chairs as they continued chatting. More laid back at the neighboring table, the former That ’70s Show star played it cool by himself before moving to the main room, where he was surrounded by people for the rest of the night.