updated 07/01/2014 AT 2:00 PM ET
•originally published 07/01/2014 AT 3:20 PM ET
Frozen fans were thrilled when Elsa appeared in Storybrooke in the Once Upon a Time season 3 finale and immediately began dreaming of their perfect choices to play the rolls of Elsa, Anna and Kristoff.
After months of anxiously waiting, two names have finally been revealed and (sadly) Kristen Bell and Jonathan Groff won’t be reprising their roles.
Greek alum and Chasing Life actor Scott Michael Foster, 29, will play hunky ice picker Kristoff and newcomer Elizabeth Lail will play Kristoff’s love interest, Anna. The Ice Queen herself has not been cast. However, we have our own list of guesses for who could play that role.